Down syndrome crossed right into the news cycle freshly when the Tennessee legislature happen the “fetal heartbeat bill,” which, among other things, prohibits any kind of abortion on account the the condition.

You are watching: Aborting a child with down syndrome



Down syndrome crossed into the news cycle recently when the state legislature passed the so-called “fetal heartbeat bill,” which, amongst other things, prohibits any abortion ~ above account that the condition.

The ban is in solution to some startling statistics. Though dependable data is scarce, the best calculations indicate that 67% the U.S. Pregnancies wherein it is said the baby would certainly be born with Down syndrome finish in abortion.


This means there were 33% under babies in the U.S. Under syndrome community born now than there would have been if those abortions had actually not occurred.”

Hear much more Tennessee Voices:Get the weekly opinion newsletter for insightful and also thought provoking columns.

The statistics in Europe are even an ext startling, where abortion prices on account of under syndrome might be greater than 90%, and Iceland claims to have actually all however eliminated down syndrome births.


*

The legislation creates "harmful effect on clinical care"

There is some debate, even among the down syndrome community, end whether banning such abortions will have actually the intended effect, specifically in a situation where medical professionals may currently lack information and may be unsure what to say to expectant mothers.

“By restraining patients’ options, the invoice would minimize the incentive to sell prenatal diagnosis, which consequently would have actually a harmful result on clinical care,” stated Ellen Clayton, a professor the pediatrics and also health plan at Vanderbilt’s center of Biomedical Ethics and also Society. “For example, without prenatal diagnosis, parents and their medical professionals would not have the opportunity they would certainly have had actually to prepare because that the bear if they had known that the fetus had a serious clinical problem. That absence of preparation might harm the children health.”


Of significantly less debate among the Down neighborhood is the idea the abortion have to not be the go-to alternative for parental who discover out they will birth a child with down syndrome. The problem is that, like Talbott’s hospital encounter, the endure parents have deserve to make all the difference.

“When the provider claims ‘the infant you’re expecting has actually Down syndrome,’ it’s followed with ‘if you going to terminate, you have actually X amount of time,” Talbott said. “Depending on when that happens, indigenous a parents perspective, it’s nearly as if it is expected, and also it scares people into thinking they can’t handle a son with down syndrome.”

So, in 2018, DSAMT and also other organizations in the state pushed for the down Syndrome details Act, a bill that required the state department of health to make obtainable updated details on under syndrome to health and wellness providers and also parents. That is currently law.

The conflict surrounding abortion and Down syndrome will not constantly be limited to under syndrome. In fact, such ethical and legal inquiries are only likely to grow an ext numerous as science provides available more prenatal testing.

“It would certainly be good if together a society we were better at sustaining all women and their family members who desire to have kids with access to health care, good information to help them make the best selection for them, and adequate assistance after birth to aid children thrive,” Clayton said.

What type of culture do we want to be?

The abortion controversy is too typically a binary one over choice or anti-choice. The questions here though room far more complex. Castle are around what kind of society we want to be.

Do we want to it is in ruthlessly loyal to science, shunting away resides that may be complicated but likewise courageous, or carry out we desire to respond through compassion and love? Compassion and love sound choose the far better option, yet it is also the hardest. It calls for us to look deep at what our society is and also what it need to be.

How deserve to we make our health-care system more easily prioritize the demands of world with disabilities, or fund our education system more fully so that kids with disabilities can learn come their best potential and contribute in their own means to enriching our society? You can’t fit the answer come that inquiry on a bumper sticker.

See more: Asking For The Bare Minimum In A Relationship Standards You Have To Set


Talbott’s son, Ron, is in school now, taking mainstream classes. He is a young Scout. He have the right to read. He have the right to swim. He may go to college or probably not, however like any type of 11-year-old, right currently he is an ext interested in functioning at a pizza shop or a Halloween costume store. His life has meaning and value.

“You deserve to imagine what that would certainly feel like in real life,” Talbott said, “if someone believed your life had no value and actually suggested that you never ever be born in the an initial place.”

Alex ha is a columnist because that USA this day Network Tennessee. Email him at dhubbard