I love a an excellent bagel, but no other food-ordering endure rouses a sense of undecided hysteria quite like picking which one I want cradling my dollop the cream cheese. The choices are endless: I could go v something savory, prefer an onion bagel. Or perhaps something sweet, prefer a blueberry one. Climate again, perhaps a level bagel would help the cream cheese stand out. Ooh, watch at the one through even an ext cheese ~ above top. 

Yeah, if friend care around your sanity, i recommend never taking me come a bagel shop. But for now, since the human being in line behind me are on the verge of bashing me over the head with a bag of week-old bagels, ns asked Dana Hunnes, an elderly dietitian at the Ronald Reagan UCLA clinical Center, to help me decide what I want by ranking one assortment the bagels by how unhealthy they room — indigenous unhealthy to seriously unhealthy.

You are watching: Are everything bagels bad for you

And sadly, together I simply suggested, yes, bagels are inherently not therefore healthy. “All of these bagels usage processed white flour, which is among the ‘white foods’ i recommend avoiding,” explains nutritionist David Friedman, author of Food Sanity: how to Eat in a human being of Fads and Fiction. What he means is, since most bagels are practically entirely white flour, which has actually virtually zero nutritional benefits, they mainly just administer empty calories, fattening you increase without providing your body anything nice.

Another thing to consider prior to jumping right into our ranking is the influence of everything you select to top your bagel with. “Avocado, hummus and also peanut butter would certainly be the best,” Hunnes says. Every one of these options carry out healthy fats that are great for her heart, and also plant-based proteins, transforming your otherwise mediocre bagel into a much more balanced meal. “Cream cheese, lox and butter are amongst the worst toppings since of the pet protein and casein . A research came native Loma Linda the other day supporting what I currently knew to it is in true: that dairy products, even little amounts, significantly increase your hazard of occurring breast cancer — and men can obtain breast cancer, too.” Still, lox is a better choice than cream cheese and also butter, since it boasts omega-3 fatty acids (which avoid heart disease), B vitamins and essential minerals.

Now, back to the bagels and our ranking…


1) Whole-Wheat Bagels: Whole-wheat bagels room the healthiest choice, states Hunnes, since they provide a an extensive amount the fiber (which helps keep your digestive device healthy), protein, vitamins, minerals and a range of phytochemicals that improve digestion, mitigate inflammation and also lower cholesterol. An ext specifically, whole-wheat bagels save on computer lactic acid, which promotes the expansion of “good bacteria” in the intestines. 

Then again, if friend want all of these benefits, you need the fix to bespeak a whole-wheat bagel as soon as there are so plenty of other, much more appealing options, which… Godspeed come you.

2) Egg Bagels: Despite eggs having actually a questionably healthy reputation, egg bagels quiet earn 2nd place on our ranking, because the visibility of eggs provides the bagel a more balanced meal. Since eggs are great sources the protein and also iron, egg bagels have around twice the lot of protein and iron when contrasted to level bagels — and some extr vitamins, to boot. Quite job, egg bagels.

3) Onion, Poppy Seed, Sesame and Everything Bagels (tied): Hunnes states these room “all on par through each other,” since the “differences are fairly mild.” In other words, when onions boast some healthy and balanced antioxidants, for instance, or if poppy seeds provide some healthy and balanced plant compounds, saying the the small amounts generally found atop bagels have actually virtually any type of nutritional influence would it is in an exaggeration. In fact, together this Healthline post on sesame seed explains, “You may need come eat significant amounts — a small handful per day — to gain health benefits.” and also even if her bagel was loaded v sesame seeds, eating a bagel a day is a poor idea.

See more:
Are There Any New Hurricanes Forming, No Tropical Development Expected In The Gulf

7) plain Bagels: Honestly, Hunnes says, nutritionally speaking, level bagels are extremely close come onion, poppy seed, sesame and also everything bagels. But since we can all use a little optimism in this doomed world, hey, also a pair poppy seeds are far better than none, right?

8) Cinnamon Raisin and Blueberry Bagels: Getting some fruit in your bagel could seem choose a an excellent idea, but as Hunnes explains, fruity bagels like these are often pumped with added sugar to carry out an extra absent of sweetness. And also as we already know, street is terrible for you, i m sorry negates any type of goodness the the fruit would otherwise provide.

10) Asiago Bagels: These space the bagels with crusted cheese top top top, which, together Hunnes explains, “are higher in calories, saturation fat , sodium and my favorite thing to talk about, casein.” She adds, “Keep in mind, too, that v the sizes of bagels these days being four ounces, we’re looking at between 300 and also 450 calories simply for the bagel alone.”