Jef (an inexplicable nickname because that Jennifer) got her master’s degree from Indiana college in April 2009 studying the mating actions of seahorses. After four years of diving off the Gulf...

You are watching: Are there any neanderthals alive today

View complete profile.

Learn about our editorial policies.

After the 2010 publication of the Neanderthal draft genome sequence, evolutionary biologist Joshua Akey, climate at the college of Washington in Seattle, and his graduate student Benjamin Vernot started looking right into its many provocative implication: that the old hominins had actually bred v the ancestors of modern humans. Neanderthals had been life in Eurasia for much more than 300 millennia when some human ancestors left Africa some 60,000–70,000 year ago, and according to the 2010 publication, in which researchers contrasted the Neanderthal draft genome with modern human sequences, about 2 percent that the DNA in the genomes the modern-day people with Eurasian family tree is Neanderthal in origin.1

To inspection the archaic ancestry of the living human population, Akey and also Vernot collection to work trying to find Neanderthal DNA in modern genomes. They arisen a statistical method to identify genetic signatures suggestive the Neanderthal genealogy in the genomes that 379 European and 286 East asian individuals. The undertaking was more powered by the an initial high-quality Neanderthal genome sequence, which provided the duo confidence the the sequences they’d identified were without doubt of antiquated origin. Still, in the ago of Akey’s mind, he had actually doubts about the research. “I remember telling Ben we were functioning on this, ‘I wake up every day in a cold sweat that this is all just incomplete lineage sorting’”—a methodological artifact that would threaten their conclusions around Neanderthal ancestry, definition the sequences to be the result of the usual ancestry the two groups shared.

Then, together Vernot and also Akey were getting ready to send their job-related for publication, their department got a visit indigenous Svante Pääbo, a geneticist in ~ the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary sociology who had actually pioneered techniques for extract and analyzing DNA from old specimens and had led the at an early stage Neanderthal genome efforts. Lock spoke through him about their ongoing project, and also Pääbo detailed that his collaborator, David Reich in ~ Harvard medical School, to be pursuing a very similar line that research. Therefore Akey gave Reich a call.

“The end result was us agreed to name: coordinates publication,” Akey recalls. “We also agreed not to even look at each other’s papers because we didn’t want to affect the outcomes in any kind of way.”

See “Simultaneous Release”

Was it simply this curious feature of human history that didn’t have actually an impact, or walk it alter the trajectory of human evolution?

Vernot and Akey submitted to Science;2 Reich and his colleagues it is registered to Nature.3 The 2 journals synchronized publication of the files at the end of January 2014. The job they go live, Akey anxiously began to read the document from the Reich group. “I remember sit in mine office, analysis it, and really type of simply going with the checklist” the the crucial results, that says. Quickly, the relief set in. “We basically said the specific same thing,” Akey recalls. “Usually as soon as you publish something, the years prior to you view validation. . . . This was type of immediate gratification.”

The two groups had used different statistical ideologies to identify Neanderthal DNA in contemporary human genomes, putting to bed any type of skepticism around the history of hominin team interbreeding. “ the final nail ~ above the coffin the it can not be something else,” claims Janet Kelso, a computational biologist at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology and also a collaborator on Reich’s publication.

With the issue of Neanderthal/modern human being mating settled, scientists could focus top top a brand-new goal, says Akey, now at Princeton University. Namely, what to be the repercussion of this interbreeding? “Was it just this curious feature of human history that didn’t have an impact, or did it change the trajectory of human evolution?”

In the past five years, a flurry of research has actually sought come answer that question. Genomic analyses have connected Neanderthal variants with distinctions in the expression level of diverse genes and also of phenotypes ranging from skin and hair color to immune duty and neuropsychiatric disease. However researchers cannot yet say how these archaic sequences influence people today, much much less the human beings who acquired them part 50,000–55,000 years ago.

“So much I have not seen any kind of convincing sensible studies where you take the Neanderthal variant and the human being variant and also do regulated experiments” to identify the physiological consequence, states Grayson Camp, a genomicist at the institute of Molecular and Clinical Ophthalmology Basel (IOB) in Switzerland. “No one has actually shown yet in society that a human and Neanderthal allele have a various physiological function. That will certainly be exciting when who does.”

A combined History

Some 350,000 or an ext years ago, the group of hominins that would evolve to come to be Neanderthals and also Denisovans left Africa for Eurasia.

A couple of hundred millennia later, around 60,000 to 70,000 year ago, the ancestors of modern-day non-Africans followed a similar path the end of Africa and began interbreeding with these other hominin groups. Researchers estimate that much of the Neanderthal DNA in modern-day human genomes came from interbreeding events that took place roughly 50,000 to 55,000 years back in the middle East. Thousands of years later, humans moving into east Asia interbred v Denisovans.


Neanderthal in ours skin

Most Neanderthal variants exist in only about 2 percent of modern-day people the Eurasian descent. However some archaic DNA is much an ext common, an indication the it was beneficial to old humans together they moved from Africa into Eurasia, i m sorry Neanderthals had dubbed home for an ext than 300,000 years. In your 2014 study, Vernot and Akey discovered several sequences of Neanderthal origin that were present in more than half of the genomes native living human beings they studied. The regions that included high frequencies of Neanderthal sequences contained genes that can yield hints to their functional effect. Base-pair differences between Neanderthal and also human variants rarely loss in protein-coding sequences, yet rather in regulation ones, arguing the archaic sequences influence gene expression. (See “Denisovans in the Mix” below.)

A variety of segments harbor genes that relate come skin biology, such together a transcription variable that regulates the development of epidermal cells called keratinocytes. This variants might underlie traits the were adaptive in the various climatic conditions and lower levels of ultraviolet light exposure at much more northern latitudes. Reich’s group similarly found genes affiliated in skin biology enriched in Neanderthal ancestry—that is, much more than simply a few percent of people carried Neanderthal DNA in these components of the genome.

No one has actually shown yet in culture that a human and Neanderthal allele have actually a different physiological function. That will be amazing when someone does.

It to be unclear, however, what details effect the Neanderthal variants had on phenotype. Because that that, researchers necessary phenotypic data on many different type of traits, combine with genetic information, for hundreds of people. Vanderbilt university evolutionary geneticist Tony Capra has access to such a resource: the digital Medical Records and also Genomics (eMERGE) Network. Right roughly the time the scientific community was beginning to map Neanderthal DNA in the genomes of life people, arise organizers were compiling digital health records and associated hereditary data for tens of countless patients from ripe health-care centers throughout the US. “We felt prefer we had a chance to evaluate several of those hypotheses ~ above a larger scale in a genuine human populace where we had actually rich phenotype data,” says Capra.

In collaboration with Akey and also Vernot, who helped identify Neanderthal variants in the genetic data included in the database, Capra’s team looked because that links in between the antiquated DNA and much more than 1,000 phenotypes across some 28,000 civilization of european ancestry. They report in 2016 that Neanderthal DNA at various sites in the genome influences a selection of immune and also autoimmune traits, and there was part association v obesity and also malnutrition, pointing come potential metabolic effects. The researchers also saw an association in between Neanderthal ancestry and also two species of noncancerous skin growths connected with dysfunctional keratinocyte biology—supporting the idea that the Neanderthal DNA to be at one allude selected for its effects on skin.4

“This to be crazy come me,” states Capra. “What these other groups had predicted based upon just the sample of occurrence—the presence and absence of Neanderthal ancestry approximately certain types of genes—we were in reality seeing in a real human being population, that having actually Neanderthal family tree influenced traits pertained to those varieties of skin cells.” What stays unclear, however, is what the benefits of the Neanderthal assignment were for those early on humans.

At the same time, Kelso and her postdoc Michael Dannemann were taking a comparable approach with a relatively new database dubbed the UK Biobank (UKB), which includes data from around fifty percent a million brother volunteers that filled the end questionnaires about themselves, underwent medical exams, and also gave blood samples because that genotyping. Formally launched in 2006, the UKB released its 500,000-person-strong resource in 2015, and Kelso and also Dannemann determined to watch what details they could extract. Conveniently, the genotyping data specifically consists of SNPs that deserve to identify variants that Neanderthal origin, many thanks to Reich’s group, which listed UKB architects with a perform of 6,000 Neanderthal variants.

Among the many links Kelso and Dannemann figured out as castle dug into data from an ext than 112,000 people in the UKB was, once again, an combination between particular Neander-thal variants and also aspects that skin biology.5 special, the antiquated sequences extending the BNC2gene—a stretch the the genome the Vernot and also Akey had determined as having Neanderthal beginning in some 70 percent that non-Africans—were very clearly associated v skin color. People who carried Neanderthal DNA there had tendency to have pale skin that melted instead of tanned, Kelso says. And also the stretch that had BNC2was just one the many, she adds: around 50 percent that Neanderthal variants connected with phenotype in her study have actually something to carry out with skin or hair color.

The result that Neanderthal DNA could have on skin appearance and function is “fascinating,” claims Akey. “Something that we’re still yes, really interested in and starting to carry out some speculative work top top is: can we know what these genes do and also then possibly what the selective push was the favored the Neanderthal version?”

See “Effects of Neanderthal DNA on contemporary Humans”

Denisovans in the mix


Neanderthals thrived in Eurasia together a leading hominin team for hundreds of thousands the years and have long been a emphasis of scientific inquiry. Yet less than a te ago, researchers uncovered that over there was an additional group of archaic hominins the coexisted with Neanderthals and the ancestors of modern-day humans. DNA gathered from a solitary finger bone and also two teeth showed up to be neither Neanderthal no one human, and also scientists named a brand-new group, the Denisovans, ~ the Siberian cavern in i m sorry the stays were uncovered in 2008.

Once researchers reconstructed the entire high-quality Denisovan genome in 2012 (Science, 338:222–26, 2012), it became clear that, choose Neanderthals, Denisovans had interbred with modern-day humans throughout the time the they coinhabited Eurasia, v analyses arguing that the introgressed DNA likely came from multiple Denisovan populations within the last 50,000 years, at some point after mixing arisen between Neanderthals and also human ancestors (Cell, 173:P53–61.E9, 2018; Cell, 177:P1010–21.E32, 2019). Denisovan DNA provides up 4–6 percent that the genomes of people native to the archipelago of Melanesia, a subregion of Oceania, and to a lesser degree they left their genetic mark in other Pacific island populations and some modern East Asians, while that is largely absent from the hereditary code of most other people. As with Neanderthal introgression, the question that continues to be to it is in answered is: What impact did these variants have on our own lineage—and room we still enduring Denisovans’ genetic influence?

As with Neanderthal DNA, professionals have determined regions of modern human genomes that are substantially depleted the Denisovan DNA, and also they observed that this “deserts” to be the exact same ones the lacked Neanderthal sequences—indications of selection against deleterious variants (Science, 352:235–39, 2016). “That’s as close as you can gain to type of a replication in this form of work,” claims Princeton college evolutionary biologist Joshua Akey. In regards to introgressed bits that Denisovan DNA that might have been helpful to contemporary humans, researcher have uncovered links to toll-like receptors and other contributors to immune function, comparable to links found with Neanderthal variants.

Denisovan DNA might have likewise offered some distinctive benefits to ancient humans. One scientific team identified Denisovan variants in the genomes that Greenland Inuits that incorporate genes involved in the advancement and distribution of adipose tissue, maybe pointing to advantages in cold tolerance and metabolism (Mol Biol Evol, 34:509–24, 2017). And also maybe the strongest suggestion of helpful Denisovan introgression originates from a 2014 study in which researchers linked the antiquated sequences v high altitude adaptation among populations the live in the Tibetan highlands (Nature, 512:194–97, 2014). The details variant they concentrated on to be so highly selected, notes Kelso, that “almost anyone living top top the plateau tote this piece of Denisovan DNA.”

Neanderthal-derived immunity

Another area of human biology tightly connected to Neanderthal variants in the genome is the immune system. Given that person ancestors to be exposed come a menagerie of various pathogens—some of which came straight from the Neanderthals—as they migrated through Eurasia, the Neanderthal sequences introgressed right into the human being genome may have helped defend against these threats, to which Neanderthals had long been exposed.

“Viral challenges, bacterial challenges are among the strongest selective forces out there,” states Kelso. Unlike changes in various other environmental conditions such as daylight patterns and UV exposure, “pathogens deserve to kill you in one generation.”

Hints of antiquated DNA’s duty in immune duty surfaced as at an early stage as 2011, as shortly as the Neanderthal genome was available for cross-referencing through sequences from modern-day humans. A team led by researcher at Stanford University uncovered that certain human leukocyte antigen (HLA) alleles, vital players in virus recognition, held signs of antiquated ancestry—from Neanderthals, but also from one more hominin cousin, the Denisovans.6 “It’s a cool file and one that added to a many of people thinking about the results of introgression,” claims Capra.

Several other studies because then have actually strengthened the attach between antiquated DNA and immune function, branching out from the HLA system to include plenty of other pathways.7 because that example, many labs have tied Neanderthal variants to changed expression level of gene encoding toll-like receptors (TLRs), an essential players in natural immune responses. In 2016, Kelso, Dannemann, and also a colleague found that microorganism response and also susceptibility to build allergies were associated with Neanderthal assignment that impact TLR production.8

Viruses, in particular, appear to be potent chauffeurs of adaptation. Critical year, university of Arizona population geneticist David Enard and also colleagues uncovered that one-third of Neanderthal variants under positive selection were attached to gene encoding proteins that communicate with viruses.9

Viral challenges, bacterial obstacles are among the strongest selective forces out there. Pathogens can kill girlfriend in one generation.

Researchers have additionally identified number of less-easily explainable phenotypic associations with Neanderthal introgression. In their 2017 analysis, for example, Kelso and also Dannemann discovered that Neanderthal variants were linked with chronotype—whether human being identify as at an early stage birds or night owls—as fine as links with susceptibility come feelings that loneliness or isolation and low enthusiasm or interest. The associations with mood-related phenotypes jibe v what Capra’s group had uncovered the year prior to in its dataset of medical information, which attached Neanderthal variants to dangers for depression and also addiction. “These were associations that were quite strong,” says Capra. “And when we looked in ~ genes wherein these regions of Neanderthal ancestry fell, in many situations they do sense given what we already know about those genes.”

Why these associations exist is still a mystery. Kelso suspects that light can be a unifying factor, with both alters in day-length patterns and also UV exposure reductions as they relocated to more-northern latitudes. Yet that’s simply a hunch, she emphasizes.

“It’s funny speculating around how might have been advantageous, or just how variants that make us depressed in the modern-day environment might have been beneficial,” claims Capra. “I don’t really even know what depression intended 40,000 years ago. It is both the challenge and the fun, provocative component about every this.”


A concern of functionality

Even with much more straightforward associations, such as with skin traits or immune responses, conclusions thus much are attracted from correlations in between genotypes and also phenotypes. While such genetic and also statistical approaches have the right to conceptually link Neander-thal introgression through phenotypes and hint in ~ why together sequences may have been selected because that in humans’ beforehand history, researchers have actually not yet published in vitro validation studies.

“Studying Neanderthal DNA much more closely on a molecular level in the lab is nice tricky,” states Dannemann. Neanderthal variants have tendency to come in packages, and also the linkage between the variants renders it an overwhelming to recognize the duty of every one, that explains.

That an obstacle hasn’t stopped researchers indigenous trying. As a postdoc in Pääbo’s laboratory in Germany, Camp, along with Vernot, Kelso, and Dannemann, developed a handful of mind organoids native induced pluripotent stem cell lines of modern-day Europeans who differ in your Neanderthal-derived genetics, and also tracked single-cell transcriptomes as the cultured cells matured. The at an early stage data indicate that the Neanderthal variants affect gene expression in the same means as recorded by previous work, validating the model.

See “Minibrains may Soon encompass Neanderthal DNA”

But such study is still in the proof-of-principle stage, says Camp, that is continuing this job-related in his very own lab in Switzerland. “Now you just need to increase throughput. You have to do this because that 100 or 200 individuals.” even then, he adds, the conclusions researcher will have the ability to draw will certainly be limited. “I to be a bit cautious and maybe downhearted you can really determine . . . Effects on some physiological outcomes.”

There room other fundamental questions that space proving complicated to answer around Neanderthal introgression, says Akey, indigenous the number of hybridization occasions to the timescale end which those occasions took place, and whether there was sex prejudice in patterns of gene flow. “There are all these vital things that room really difficult to estimate,” he says. “I think the field is sort of stuck right now.” however he’s positive that as much more genomes indigenous various archaic hominin groups and also from contemporary humans come online, researchers’ strength to design how every one of these groups interbred will strengthen. A second high-quality Neanderthal genome was released in 2017 (Science, 358:655–58), and also researchers now have the genome the a 40,000-year-old person who had actually a Neanderthal ancestor simply a few generations back. Last year, researchers released the sequence of afirst-generation hybrid that Denisovans and also Neanderthals.

See “Girl had a Denisovan Dad and also Neanderthal Mom”

Those data will likely yield part surprises. Capra has found evidence, because that example, that few of the Neanderthal segment that correlated with modern phenotypes might not influence those pheno-types directly. His work has actually uncovered instances in i beg your pardon the correlation was propelled by order close enough in the genome come Neanderthal variants that the two constantly appear together. This sequences were lugged by the common ancestor the Neanderthals and contemporary humans yet were absent from the group of humans who started the modern Eurasian population. These variants, which had actually been kept by Neanderthals, were then reintroduced come the ancestors of contemporary non-Africans during periods of interbreeding.10 “These genetic variants exist in modern-day in the Neanderthal context, but these were no of Neanderthal ancestry,” Capra says.

Akey has actually come upon another interesting twist: africans do have actually Neanderthal ancestry. Unpublished work-related from his group points come the possibility that few of the ancient modern-day humans that bred with Neanderthals migrated ago to Africa, where they blended with the modern humans there, sharing bits of Neanderthal DNA. If true, the would mean that Africa is not devoid the Neanderthals’ genetic influence, Akey notes. “There’s Neanderthal basically anywhere the world.”

All around Regulation


In your seminal 2014 studies, the teams of David Reich of Harvard clinical School and also Joshua Akey, climate at the college of Washington, provided that the Neanderthal variants that associated with human being phenotypes go not appear in coding regions. 2 years later, a genome-wide analysis published by investigators in France uncovered that Neanderthal family tree was enriched in locations tied come gene regulation (Cell, 167:643–56.e17, 2016). The implicit was the sequences the originated in Neanderthals have tendency to have actually “less influence through protein and more impact through gene expression,” states coauthor Maxime Rotival, a geneticist at the Pasteur academy in Paris.

To questioning this question more directly, Akey turned come the Genotype-Tissue Expression (GTEx) Project, which has actually cataloged gene expression data from around 50 tissues because that each that 10,000 individuals. “It’s this really fine-scale record of gene expression,” claims Akey. His then-postdoc Rajiv McCoy, currently an assistant professor at Johns Hopkins University, arisen a method to evaluate messenger RNA levels based on which allele to be being expressed—the one native an individual’s dad or mother—and the researchers used this method to world in the GTEx database who were heterozygous for a certain Neanderthal variant. Compare expression levels based upon which allele to be being expressed, the researchers discovered that a 4 minutes 1 of the follow me of Neanderthal DNA in human genomes influence the regulation of the genes in or close to those stretches (Cell, 168:P916–27.E12, 2017).

“We’ve well-known for a lengthy time the gene expression variation is vital source of phenotypic variation in ~ populations and also phenotypic divergence in between species,” states Akey. “We were interested in asking whether Neanderthal order make any kind of contribution to gene expression variability.” The answer was a resounding yes.

Earlier this year, Rotival and two colleagues calculated ratios the Neanderthal come non-Neanderthal variants throughout the genome and also compared those ratios for protein-codingregions and various regulatory sequences, especially enhancers, promoters, and also microRNA-binding sites. Regular with ahead results, they found a strong depletion the Neanderthal variants in coding portions of genes, and a slight enrichment the the antiquated sequences in regulatory regions (Am J Hum Genet, doi:10.1016/j.ajhg.2019.04.016, 2019). “What we watch is that in coding regions, the proportion of archaic to non-archaic variants is much smaller than the ratio outside of coding regions,” says Rotival.

“This is no at every a surprise,” says Vanderbilt University’s Tony Capra, who lab has actually generated comparable findings in world of Eurasian descent, “but it’s really nice to check out it quantified really comprehensively.”


Jef Akst is the regulating editor the The Scientist. Email her atjakst

Clarification (September 26): This story has actually been update to readjust mentions the “non-African” descent or family tree to “Eurasian” to prevent confusion. All contemporary humans have ancestry in Africa.

See more: Aliens Coming To Earth In 3 Months, Alien Contact: What Happens Next

The Scientistregrets any kind of confusion.

evolutionevolutionary biologygeneticsgenetics & genomicsgenomicshomininhominin evolutionhomininshuman evolution