The magazine of the Catholic Diocese of Lansing


Main Nav confidence Mag

your Life Your confidence News

In his work, “The world’s Religions,” writer Huston blacksmith highlights an 19th century Hindu saint, Ramakrishna, as an illustration the a conviction that the various major religions are alternative paths come the same goal. Ramakrishna, after enduring each the the significant religions, concluded that there existed crucial unity amongst them. That wrote, “God has made different religions to suit different aspirations, times, and countries. All doctrines are just so countless paths; yet a path is through no way God Himself.” A more modern version the this discussion runs choose this: all religions are like the spokes the a wheel the all finish in the very same center. The question, of course, is deserve to this it is in right?

A Return to ancient Wisdom

Let us revolve to Aristotle’s regulation of non-contradiction in our consideration of the validity of universalism, or universal salvation. This legislation states the opposite truth cases cannot both be true, and also it continues to be instructive as we discover the argument that all religious beliefs are ultimately different paths to the same God.

You are watching: Belief that all religions are true

The truth is the every faith makes absolute fact claims about God. For example, Catholics and other believer declare that God is a Trinitarian communion that Father, Son, and also the holy Spirit. Islam holds that God is merely one. Hinduism acknowledges the existence of thousands of deities, when Buddhism appears to be without a belief in God, at least a an individual God.

In terms of logic, we can affirm the validity of this diversity that absolute fact claims about God from a subjective suggest of view. Over there is no reason to doubt the earnestness of the ideas held through the faithful of each religion. However, the regulation of non-contradiction seems to dominance out the opportunity that each religion’s expertise of God is same valid and also true native an objective point of view.

This would certainly seem to imply that all religions perform not eventually lead to the same God because all religions execute not think in the very same God. The exemption to this might be if all religious beliefs are same wrong about who God is. This, that course, would median that all religious beliefs are same invalid and also untrue, which eventually undermines every religions due to the fact that they rest specifically on your absolute reality claims.

What go the Church say?

On Oct. 28, 1965, Pope Paul through issued the Vatican II document entitled the declaration on the relationship of the Church come Non-Christian religions (Nostra Aetate). It identifies the desire and also search because that God as one of the significant factors the contributes to the unity of every peoples. It likewise acknowledges the methods other religious beliefs have understood God and also humanity’s connection to God.

Most significantly, Nostra Aetate states, “The Catholic Church rejects nothing the is true and holy in this religions. She regards with sincere reverence those methods of conduct and also of life, those precepts and also teachings which, though differing in many aspects from the persons she holds and sets forth, nonetheless frequently reflect a ray of that truth which enlightens all.”

At the very same time, the paper makes that clear the the Church, “proclaims, and ever need to proclaim Christ ‘the way, the truth, and also the life’ (John 14:6), in who may find the fullness of spiritual life, in whom God has actually reconciled all things to Himself.”

Catholics are called to affirm and also celebrate the fact wherever that is encountered. However, this is not the same as proclaiming all faiths to be different paths to the very same God. The Church holds to the absolute truth claim that the fullness that the fact resides in the Catholic faith, because that the reality is a person, Jesus Christ, and also the Church is his body.

In closing

It is true the all major religions re-superstructure some points in common: a wisdom tradition, some variation of the gold Rule, and articles that faith. However, together Huston smith notes in his final chapter, as soon as one moves beyond such pass out generalities, one discovers that religious beliefs differ substantially in what is thought about essential. He looks to the schisms between Hinduism and Buddhism; in between Judaism, Christianity and also Islam; and also within Christianity itself to underscore the point.

See more: The Real Ages Of Real Housewives Of New York ? How Old Are The Real Housewives Of New York

The argument that all faiths are various paths come the same God appeals come our desire for unity and togetherness. However, the price because that such a belief is twofold. First, one must overlook the actual differences in between religions on essential questions. This is a form of minimization that refuses come take spiritual beliefs seriously in the name of a false unity. Second, one should actually delegitimize religion altogether, albeit in the name of respecting every religions, by heralding all absolute truth claims of religion to be merely relative. V this, the arduous search for genuine truth is abandoned.